Fluffernutter Cookie

Level Up Bakery Verified independent store

→

Meet the cookie that tastes like childhood nostalgia turned all the way up. Our Fluffernutter Cookie is a thick, bakery-style peanut butter cookie stuffed with a creamy marshmallow center, peanut butter chips, white chocolate and finished with golden cookie crumble for that soft, gooey bite everyone is obsessed with. It’s sweet, nutty, fluffy, and perfectly over-the-top in the best way — the kind of cookie that feels like a peanut butter sandwich, a marshmallow treat, and a bakery dessert all in one. Perfect for peanut butter lovers, cookie box add-ons, gift boxes, or anyone who loves a soft stuffed cookie with a little crunch. Flavor notes: peanut butter, marshmallow cream, buttery cookie dough, golden cookie crumbleTexture: thick, soft, gooey, creamy, slightly crunchyBest enjoyed: room temp or warmed for 8–10 seconds Allergen notice: Contains wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, and may contain or come in contact with tree nuts, soy, and other allergens. Show more