Authentic Key Lime Pie (4 Sizes Available)

Sweet Chef Southern Style Bakery Verified independent store

→

The ultimate balance of tart and sweet. Our Authentic Key Lime Pie is a refreshing Southern staple that brings a burst of tropical sunshine to New York City. We don't do "green" pi es—we do real pies, made with premium lime juice and a silky-smooth sweetened cream base. Every pie is nestled into our signature handcrafted graham cracker crust, which provides a salty-sweet, buttery crunch that perfectly complements the zesty filling. It’s light, tangy, and incredibly satisfying. Choose Your Perfect Size: 10-Inch Deep Dish: The star of the show for summer BBQs and large celebrations. 8-Inch Classic: Perfect for a refreshing family dessert. 6-Inch Small Batch: Just enough for a sweet date night at home. 4-Inch Personal Size: A zesty, grab-and-go treat that’s better than any candy bar. Why You’ll Love Our Key Lime Pie: Real Lime Zest: We use citrus juice and zest to ensure a bright, natural flavor that cuts through the richness. Graham Cracker Perfection: Our crust is thick, buttery, and baked to a perfect golden brown—no soggy bottoms here. The "Cool" Dessert: The perfect palate cleanser after a heavy meal or a hot day in the city. Serving Suggestion: Serve chilled! For the full experience, top with a dollop of fresh whipped cream and a thin slice of fresh lime. Available for local NYC pickup and delivery. Order your favorite size at asweetchef.com and taste the zest. Show more