Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter 👻🍪 One bite will have you feeling like a kid again. Inspired by the classic oatmeal cream cookie, Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter starts with our smooth, small-batch almond butter infused with soft oatmeal cookie flavor and warm brown sugar notes. Every jar is hand-finished with creamy vanilla frosting, premium white chocolate chips, and an entire oatmeal cream-filled cookie for the perfect balance of chewy cookie, sweet filling, and creamy almond butter. It’s everything you loved about opening that lunchbox treat—only even better by the spoonful. Whether you’re celebrating spooky season or simply craving a nostalgic dessert, this limited-edition flavor is guaranteed to disappear fast. Perfect For Eating straight from the spoon Graham crackers and pretzels Apple slices and bananas Toast and English muffins Oatmeal and yogurt Ice cream and dessert toppings Part of our Almond Unlock Vault Collection, these retired fan favorites have been unlocked for a limited time. Once the vault closes, they’ll disappear until their next return.
