Not sure which Tooth Puddy is right for you? This bundled set lets you experience both formulas at a reduced cost so you can discover which one best fits your preferences and lifestyle. While the ingredients and texture are different, both puddies are designed with the same purpose in mind: supporting remineralization, strengthening enamel, soothing sensitivity, and promoting overall oral health. Neither formula is better than the other. They simply take different approaches to achieving the same goal. Many customers see excellent results with either formula—the choice often comes down to ingredient preferences, dietary considerations, and texture. If you're unsure which formula is right for you, this Discovery Set is the perfect way to try both and find your favorite. Lovingly smear on clean, dry teeth. Dry the teeth before applying the puddy to improve adherence. Apply as often as you like, but recommend night application Leave the puddyy on as long as you like, but we recommend leaving in on overnight and remove when brushing teeth. If the puddy falls off or doesn't stay exactly where you placed it, that's perfectly okay! The minerals are still being introduced into your saliva, which helps distribute them throughout the mouth and support the remineralization process. Original Formula Our Original Puddy takes an herbal, plant-based approach to remineralization. It combines coral-derived micro-hydroxyapatite with traditional Ayurvedic and Chinese herbs that have long been used to support bone, tooth, and gum health. It is also a great option for vegetarians and those avoiding animal-derived ingredients. Highlights: Coral Micro-Hydroxyapatite Organic Sesame Oil Base Ozonated Oil for Antimicrobial Support Infused with Ayurvedic & Chinese Medicinal Herbs Vegan-friendly and free from meat, milk, and eggs Primal Puddy Formula Primal Puddy takes an ancestral, nutrient-dense approach. It features a sophisticated mineral matrix including oyster shell, pearl, shilajit, trace minerals, and bovine colostrum. Its grass-fed tallow base naturally contains vitamins K2 and D3, nutrients known for their role in directing minerals where they belong. Primal Puddy is typically easier to apply thanks to its thicker, stickier texture. Because it contains animal-based ingredients, it may have a naturally earthy or barn-like aroma from the Tallow. Highlights: Bovine Micro-Hydroxyapatite Grass-Fed Tallow Base Rich in Vitamins K2 & D3 Contains Bovine Colostrum Ultra-nourishing, creamy texture Animal-based ancestral ingredients