BreakingT
Matthew Schaefer Hockey
USD 30.00
L'ATELIER DES CARTES
MATTHEW SCHAEFER ROUND DRAFT
CAD 11.95
✦
Rip It Sports Cards
Matthew Schaefer signed puck
USD 599.99
Otters' Den
Matthew Schaefer Jersey Relic
USD 25.00
Nova's Sports Cards
Matthew Schaefer #451 Young Guns
CAD 300.00
CracknCarve
Matthew Schaefer – New York Islanders Collectible
CAD 45.00
Ink Ritual Co
Matthew Schaefer Hockey T-Shirts, Hoodie, Sweatshirt
USD 18.94
shopfanwear
Matthew Schaefer New York I Elite WHT
USD 36.99
Rémi Card Trader
Chandail Officiel Autographié Fanatics Premium - Matthew Sch
CAD 999.95
Double Steve Cards & C
2025-26 Upper Deck #451 Matthew Schaefer
USD 230.00
LimoTee
Matthew Schaefer - Name Pose - New York Hockey
USD 24.94
Delco Rips Cards
2025-26 Upper Deck #451 Matthew Schaefer
USD 185.00
Pod Tees Hub
Officials Matthew Schaefer Hockey T-Shirts, Hoodie, Sweatshi
USD 23.94
Mintink Trading Cards
2025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Young Guns
CAD 375.00
Piece Of The Game
Matthew Schaefer 2026 Topps Now Sticker #110
USD 9.99
Isles Lab
New York Islanders Centerfold Puck | Matthew Schaefer
USD 20.00
Let's Play! Cards and
Matthew Schaefer #PP-4 Premium Prospects (cabinet-NM)
CAD 14.99
Tee Hivey
Premium Matthew Schaefer Team Marcus Foligno Face Off
USD 23.94
✦
Replay Sports Cards
2025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Young Guns RC
USD 200.00
Great American Sports
Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum #268
USD 10.00
Roster Jersey
Men's New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer #71 Jersey
USD 28.98
Classic Authentics
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Official NHL Jersey
USD 99.99
✦
Aces Sports Cards
2026 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Rookie Class Red
USD 30.00
Right Off The Field
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Jersey Size 52
USD 79.99
Smo's Custom Cards
Matthew Schaefer Emergent NHL Dual Islanders / Shield Patche
USD 65.00
NordSlab
2025 Upper Deck #451 Matthew Schaefer PSA 9 Mint
CAD 360.00
Player X
Matthew Schaefer Autographed New York Islanders Fanatics Pre
CAD 1,050.00
CoolHockey.ca
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Premium Home Je
CAD 199.99
Frozen Pond
Matthew Schaefer Autographed New York Islanders Pro Jersey -
CAD 950.00
canvasartprous
Matthew Schaefer Islanders Jersey Canvas Print | Wall Art De
USD 37.95
Pop Flex Tees
Matthew Schaefer Hockey Long Island Skating T-Shirts, Hoodie
USD 18.94
GameOn!Ottawa
NHL Player Replica Breakaway Jersey Home Matthew Schaefer Is
CAD 209.99
The Sports Shaq
Michael Misa / Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 Upper Deck #500
USD 5.00
Ice Gems Collectibles
2025-26 Matthew Schaefer Fleer Ultra Hockey Rookie #164
USD 100.00
Certified Sports LLC
New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer Blue Stitched Game Jerse
USD 80.00
SV Sports & Trading Ca
2025 Upper Deck MVP Matthew Schaefer #275 Copper Script
USD 70.00
CoolHockey.com
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Premium Home Je
USD 179.99
Trading Card Market
2026 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer Rookie Refractor Isl
USD 20.00
Bears BMX & BS
NHL - New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer Premium Home Jerse
CAD 315.00
Albion Cards
MATTHEW SCHAEFER - 2025 Upper Deck Young Guns #451, PSA 9
USD 250.00
Aftrfx Studios
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders NHL Wall Art Poster | La
USD 19.99
Three Stars Sportscard
Matthew Schaefer 2025 Upper Deck Rookie #451 PSA 9 Mint 1985
USD 350.00
Clubhouse Cards
#RC-1 MATTHEW SCHAEFER 2025 TOPPS NOW ISLANDERS sports BLACK
USD 90.00
YinzerShop
Matthew Schaefer Hooded Sweatshirt - Midweight Cotton Polyes
USD 54.99
Sports Jersey Direct
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Home Hockey Jersey – Roy
USD 44.99
Blue Breaks Sports Car
Topps Now - Matthew Schaefer - New York Islanders - Ice Hock
USD 20.00
Patricia Michon Store
Men's New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer Fanatics Royal Pla
USD 56.99
Little Shop of Cards L
2025-26 Series Two Matthew Schaefer RC Population Count 1000
USD 100.00