Atypical Treasures

5077 products

At Atypical Treasures, we specialize in unique collectibles and carefully selected finds for true enthusiasts. Whether you're hunting for rare pieces or timeless favorites, our goal is simple: bring you treasures worth keeping.

Atypical Treasures

All products

All Home page Clothing Toys Collectables Hobbies Home & Decor Media Electronics
Vintage Schlitz 4-sided Beer Tap Handle made of Plastic 4.5" tall

Vintage Schlitz 4-sided Beer Tap Handle made of Plastic 4.5"

USD 18.99
Vintage Ertl Budweiser World Famous Clydesdales Horse Bank 1941 Ford 1:43

Vintage Ertl Budweiser World Famous Clydesdales Horse Bank 1

USD 16.0
1999 Mary Beth's Bean Bag World Collector Edition 3D Hologram Trading Card

1999 Mary Beth's Bean Bag World Collector Edition 3D Hologra

USD 2.99
1995 Image Quilts Florida Gators Limited Edition Quilt Blanket COA Unopened

1995 Image Quilts Florida Gators Limited Edition Quilt Blank

USD 249.99
Vintage Gemmy Lighted Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Halloween Decor 14" Tested Works

Vintage Gemmy Lighted Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Halloween Decor

USD 39.99
1996 Disney 101 Dalmatians Snow Dome McDonald's Happy Meal Toy Lot of 4 w/Boxes

1996 Disney 101 Dalmatians Snow Dome McDonald's Happy Meal T

USD 14.99
McDonald's Disney 102 Dalmatians Happy Meal Display Case w/ Sealed Toys 2000

McDonald's Disney 102 Dalmatians Happy Meal Display Case w/

USD 99.95
Vintage YoungAn Trustworthy Hardware Wichita KS Trucker Snapback Hat OSFA

Vintage YoungAn Trustworthy Hardware Wichita KS Trucker Snap

USD 33.33
Vintage Mattel MOTU Man-E-Faces Masters of the Universe Action Figure Loose

Vintage Mattel MOTU Man-E-Faces Masters of the Universe Acti

USD 9.99
Warren Moon HOF 06 Signed Houston Oilers Riddell Speed Helmet BAS Witness FS

Warren Moon HOF 06 Signed Houston Oilers Riddell Speed Helme

USD 249.99
1984 Coleco Cabbage Patch Kids 14" Preemie Girl Doll Box Receipt Hong Kong

1984 Coleco Cabbage Patch Kids 14" Preemie Girl Doll Box Rec

USD 79.99
2007 McDonald's Wizard of Oz Wicked Witch of the West #3 Happy Meal Toy Bagged

2007 McDonald's Wizard of Oz Wicked Witch of the West #3 Hap

USD 2.99
Vintage Texas Instruments Speak & Read Electronic Learning Aid Tested Works

Vintage Texas Instruments Speak & Read Electronic Learning A

USD 19.99
1995 1996 1998 McDonald's Halloween Happy Meal Toys Lot Of 12 Sealed Loose

1995 1996 1998 McDonald's Halloween Happy Meal Toys Lot Of 1

USD 59.95
Vintage Sonic Ranger Action Figures Set of 4 Sealed Carded Robot Heroes

Vintage Sonic Ranger Action Figures Set of 4 Sealed Carded R

USD 28.99
Lladro #6274 Daisy Girl Figurine 7" Retired 2002 Jose Puche Spain Porcelain

Lladro #6274 Daisy Girl Figurine 7" Retired 2002 Jose Puche

USD 94.99
1997 Disney 101 Dalmations The Series McDonalds Happy Meal Toy Sealed Lot of 4

1997 Disney 101 Dalmations The Series McDonalds Happy Meal T

USD 10.99
Vintage Coca Cola 5 Cent Yellow Advertising 2 Blade Pocket Knife USA Made

Vintage Coca Cola 5 Cent Yellow Advertising 2 Blade Pocket K

USD 24.99
Stephen King Misery 1987 First Edition Hardcover Viking DJ $18.95 Unclipped

Stephen King Misery 1987 First Edition Hardcover Viking DJ $

USD 22.99
Goebel Hummel Apple Tree Boy 142/1 TMK5 West Germany Figurine 5.75" Tall

Goebel Hummel Apple Tree Boy 142/1 TMK5 West Germany Figurin

USD 17.99
Rare Discontinued New Era Logo Elements Cleveland Indians Chief Wahoo L/XL Hat

Rare Discontinued New Era Logo Elements Cleveland Indians Ch

USD 109.99
1994 McDonalds Happy Birthday Happy Meal 2 Complete Sets Toys Bags Boxes Lot

1994 McDonalds Happy Birthday Happy Meal 2 Complete Sets Toy

USD 66.95
Vintage Masters of the Universe Screeech Bird w Perch Harness 1983 Mattel

Vintage Masters of the Universe Screeech Bird w Perch Harnes

USD 14.99
Vintage NWT Twins Enterprise Minnesota Twins M Mesh Trucker Snapback Hat MLB

Vintage NWT Twins Enterprise Minnesota Twins M Mesh Trucker

USD 44.99