Atypical Treasures

5200 products

At Atypical Treasures, we specialize in unique collectibles and carefully selected finds for true enthusiasts. Whether you're hunting for rare pieces or timeless favorites, our goal is simple: bring you treasures worth keeping.

Atypical Treasures

All products

All Home page Clothing Toys Collectables Hobbies Home & Decor Media Electronics

Vintage Schlitz 4-sided Beer Tap Handle made of Plastic 4.5" tall

Vintage Schlitz 4-sided Beer Tap Handle made of Plastic 4.5"

Vintage Ertl Budweiser World Famous Clydesdales Horse Bank 1941 Ford 1:43

Vintage Ertl Budweiser World Famous Clydesdales Horse Bank 1

Indiana Jones #08 Funko POP Die-Cast Opened w/ Acrylic Case & Box

Indiana Jones #08 Funko POP Die-Cast Opened w/ Acrylic Case

Inge-Glas Jacob Marley Ghost A Christmas Carol Glass Ornament Germany 4.5"

Inge-Glas Jacob Marley Ghost A Christmas Carol Glass Ornamen

Dept 56 North Pole Santa's Lookout Tower 56294 Retired Lighted Building Box

Dept 56 North Pole Santa's Lookout Tower 56294 Retired Light

Dept 56 Up Up & Away Animated Santa Reindeer Sleigh 52593 Retired 1999 tested

Dept 56 Up Up & Away Animated Santa Reindeer Sleigh 52593 Re

Notre Dame 1988 National Champions Team Signed Jersey 10 Autos BAS Witness

Notre Dame 1988 National Champions Team Signed Jersey 10 Aut

Jung Hoo Lee Signed San Francisco Giants #51 Jersey Korean Auto Beckett XL

Jung Hoo Lee Signed San Francisco Giants #51 Jersey Korean A

Dept 56 Gumdrop Tree 52967 9 in LED Lighted Village Accessory Tested Box

Dept 56 Gumdrop Tree 52967 9 in LED Lighted Village Accessor

Pleasant Company American Girl Samantha 1989 Birthday Dress Fan Hanger Vintage

Pleasant Company American Girl Samantha 1989 Birthday Dress

Inge-Glas Friendly Solicitor Dickens Christmas Carol Glass Ornament Germany 5"

Inge-Glas Friendly Solicitor Dickens Christmas Carol Glass O

Dept 56 Frosty's Sleds N Saucers 56449 North Pole Animated Lighted 2005 Working

Dept 56 Frosty's Sleds N Saucers 56449 North Pole Animated L

Dept 56 Kringle Street Snowman 56833 North Pole 2002 Limited Edition Box

Dept 56 Kringle Street Snowman 56833 North Pole 2002 Limited

Vintage Christmas Annual Holiday Books Lot Augsburg Vol 37 40 44 1967 1970 1984

Vintage Christmas Annual Holiday Books Lot Augsburg Vol 37 4

Indian Motorcycles Flying A Porcelain-Style Sign – 17.5"x12" Repro Garage Decor

Indian Motorcycles Flying A Porcelain-Style Sign – 17.5"x12"

Dept 56 Peppermint Trees 56721 Village Accessories Set of 3 Original Box

Dept 56 Peppermint Trees 56721 Village Accessories Set of 3

Dept 56 Tillie’s Tiny Cup Cafe 56401 North Pole Elf Land Lighted Building

Dept 56 Tillie’s Tiny Cup Cafe 56401 North Pole Elf Land Lig

1996 McDonald's Space Jam Taz Plush Looney Tunes Tasmanian Devil Tag 8"

1996 McDonald's Space Jam Taz Plush Looney Tunes Tasmanian D

Department 56 Checking It Twice Wind-Up Toys 56757 North Pole Set 2003 Working

Department 56 Checking It Twice Wind-Up Toys 56757 North Pol

Dept 56 Sweet Rock Candy Co 56725 North Pole Series 9 Pc Gift Set 2000

Dept 56 Sweet Rock Candy Co 56725 North Pole Series 9 Pc Gif

Vintage Miller Genuine Draft MGD Black 4 Sided Wood Beer Tap Handle 9 Inch

Vintage Miller Genuine Draft MGD Black 4 Sided Wood Beer Tap

Dept 56 Cruisin’ Crayola Elves 56800 North Pole Village Set of 2 Box

Dept 56 Cruisin’ Crayola Elves 56800 North Pole Village Set

Vintage Miller Genuine Draft Light MGDL Acrylic Beer Tap Handle Amber Clear 5 In

Vintage Miller Genuine Draft Light MGDL Acrylic Beer Tap Han

Roman Kogei Musical Angel Silent Night Spinning Japan Vintage Xmas

Roman Kogei Musical Angel Silent Night Spinning Japan Vintag