Atypical Treasures

5102 products

At Atypical Treasures, we specialize in unique collectibles and carefully selected finds for true enthusiasts. Whether you're hunting for rare pieces or timeless favorites, our goal is simple: bring you treasures worth keeping.

Atypical Treasures

All products

All Home page Clothing Toys Collectables Hobbies Home & Decor Media Electronics

Vintage Schlitz Beer Tap Handle Wood, Plastic, & Brass 10.5" tall

Vintage Schlitz Beer Tap Handle Wood, Plastic, & Brass 10.5"

Bud Light Aluminum Blue Logo Beer Tap Handle 12” Tall

Vintage Halloween Ghost String Lights 10 Light UL Tested Working 10.5 Ft

Vintage Halloween Ghost String Lights 10 Light UL Tested Wor

Western Electric Bell System Qwest Coin Pay Phone Wall Telephone w/ Coin Box Key

Western Electric Bell System Qwest Coin Pay Phone Wall Telep

Vintage Empire Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Candy Bucket Trick Or Treat 7" Pail

Vintage Empire Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Candy Bucket Trick Or

Vintage Sierra Vista California Rooster Cookie Jar 1950s Ceramic Chicken Farmhouse

Vintage Sierra Vista California Rooster Cookie Jar 1950s Cer

1995 Image Quilts Florida Gators Limited Edition Quilt Blanket COA Unopened

1995 Image Quilts Florida Gators Limited Edition Quilt Blank

Vintage Gemmy Lighted Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Halloween Decor 14" Tested Works

Vintage Gemmy Lighted Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Halloween Decor

Pyrex 945-C Verde Olive Branch Replacement Lid Divided Casserole Cover USA

Pyrex 945-C Verde Olive Branch Replacement Lid Divided Casse

1998 Wells Fargo Concord Stagecoach Cast Metal Coin Bank w/ Insert No Key

1998 Wells Fargo Concord Stagecoach Cast Metal Coin Bank w/

Lladro #6274 Daisy Girl Figurine 7" Retired 2002 Jose Puche Spain Porcelain

Lladro #6274 Daisy Girl Figurine 7" Retired 2002 Jose Puche

Goebel Hummel Apple Tree Boy 142/1 TMK5 West Germany Figurine 5.75" Tall

Goebel Hummel Apple Tree Boy 142/1 TMK5 West Germany Figurin

Harley-Davidson Official Licensed Blue Neon Wall Clock Ace Product Working

Harley-Davidson Official Licensed Blue Neon Wall Clock Ace P

Vintage Coleman The Air-O-Lantern QL Gas Lantern Nickel Fount No Globe Untested

Vintage Coleman The Air-O-Lantern QL Gas Lantern Nickel Foun

Antique Griswold No 954 Cast Iron Corn Bread Stick Pan Erie Pennsylvania USA

Antique Griswold No 954 Cast Iron Corn Bread Stick Pan Erie

Starbucks 2014 Mint Green White Ribbed Textured 14oz Ceramic Coffee Mug

Starbucks 2014 Mint Green White Ribbed Textured 14oz Ceramic

Occupied Japan Boy Girl Couple Figurine Hand Painted Porcelain 4.5in Vintage

Occupied Japan Boy Girl Couple Figurine Hand Painted Porcela

Goebel Hummel Little Fiddler Violin Boy Figurine W Germany Bee V 5in Vintage

Goebel Hummel Little Fiddler Violin Boy Figurine W Germany B

3M Jumpin Bookshelf Game 1964 Complete Strategy Board Game Metal Pawns

3M Jumpin Bookshelf Game 1964 Complete Strategy Board Game M

Kellogg's Disney Pixar Finding Dory Color Changing Projection Night Light 2016

Kellogg's Disney Pixar Finding Dory Color Changing Projectio

Orchard Lodge Three Piece Gift Set Small Frames

Orchard Lodge Three Piece Gift Set Small Frames

Hallmark Keepsake Lot of 2 Gift of Peace & Glad Tidings Ornament Angels NIB

Hallmark Keepsake Lot of 2 Gift of Peace & Glad Tidings Orna

Enesco Treasure Tree Mother Ornament Rose Floral Enameled Boxed Gift

Enesco Treasure Tree Mother Ornament Rose Floral Enameled Bo

Enesco Pennywhistle Lane Stanley Bear w/Red Vest & Bow Tie Figurine

Enesco Pennywhistle Lane Stanley Bear w/Red Vest & Bow Tie F