Sterye Mystery Boxes
Sterye is your go to for playful, offbeat merch like our horror boxes, cute accessories, and themed mystery kits designed to be fun and exciting.
Sterye Mystery Boxes
All products
All
All Sterye Products
Best Sellers
Collections And Boxes
Cottage
Cherry Collection
Summer Horror Collection
Halloween 2025 Collection
Buttoneyes Collection
Plushie Collection
Blind Bag Collection
Gift & Bundles
Creepmas Collection
all
Under $30
Horror Valentines 2026
Quick Order
Sweet Season Collection
Horror Collection
The Horror Mystery Box
USD 40.0
The Halloween Mystery Box - 3 Different Sizes
USD 20.0
Mystery Bag (2-4 small mystery Items)
USD 15.0
Spooky Safe Shipping Insurance
USD 2.95
Horror Valentines Collection Box
USD 68.0
Creepmas Collection Box
USD 75.0
Mystery 24oz Spooky Tumbler
USD 25.0
The Cherry Gift Box
USD 58.0
The Cottage Box (New Box coming TBD..)
USD 60.0
Shroomers Mushroom Enamel Pin Blind Bag
USD 8.0
Cherry Tote Bag
USD 34.0
Horror Essential's Box Bundle (8 items)
USD 76.5
Lucibaa Demon Goat Plushie – 10-Inch Collectible
USD 36.0
Strawberry Cow Milk Carton
USD 10.0
Overstock Mystery Box
USD 21.5
$50 Mystery Gift Box
USD 50.0
Psychedelic Horror Umbrella
USD 28.0
Buttoneyes Plushie Blind Bag
USD 20.0
Merry Krampus Woven Creepmas Throw Blanket (PRE-ORDER)
USD 70.0
Pink Scary Movies Mini Backpack
USD 19.0
Red Horror Mini Backpack
USD 19.0
Mystery Horror T-Shirt
USD 29.0
Spooky Seas Box
USD 72.5
Cozy Krampus Horror Bundle (5 items)
USD 64.0