Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee
Dave's Sweet Tooth should come with a warning, “open and consume at your own risk”. The risk of course is finishing it all in one sitting!
Browse by category
Collections
Home page
Best Sellers
Special Flavors & Seasonal
Express Toffee Combos
All Toffee
Gift Jars - 1/2 Pound Specialty Toffee Flavors
Pouches
Seasonal
Small Batch Flavors
Apparel
Gift Cards & Merch
Bundles
All Flavors
Corporate Gifts
Birthdays
Special Occasion
Just Because
$5 Bag Sale
Black(out) Friday 2025
Not Toffee
Pretzels
Christmas in July
Featured products
Popular right now
Milk Chocolate Toffee
USD 6.99
Dark Chocolate Toffee
USD 6.99
Peanut Butter Crunch Toffee
USD 6.99
Dark Chocolate Cherry Toffee
USD 6.99
Coffee Toffee
USD 6.99
POUCH COLLECTION
USD 39.95
Gift Card
USD 5.00
White Chocolate Vanilla Bean Toffee
USD 16.99
Maple Bourbon Pecan
USD 8.99
Gingerbread Toffee
USD 7.99
Dark Chocolate Peppermint Toffee
USD 7.99
Blueberry Crunch
USD 7.99
MAGA Tears Toffee
USD 15.99
S'mores Toffee
USD 8.99
Piña Colada Toffee - 8oz Jar
USD 16.99
Birthday Cake Toffee
USD 15.99
Coconut Pretzel
USD 8.99
Cinnamon French Toast
USD 15.99
3 Pack Gift Set
USD 25.97
Cookies and Cream
USD 15.99
Raspberry Donut Toffee
USD 7.99
Lemon Bar Toffee
USD 7.99
Apple Cinnamon Whiskey
USD 7.99
Eggnog with Bourbon
USD 7.99