Buttermilk Bakery
Browse by category
Collections
Featured products
Popular right now
Custom Cookie Order
USD 36.00
6 pack- Small Hot Chocolate Bombs- up to 2 flavors per-order
USD 18.00
Thanksgiving Paint Your Own Cookies
USD 4.00
DIY Decorating Kit
USD 18.00
Paint Your Own Christmas Cookies
USD 4.00
8 Chocolate Covered Oreos
USD 15.00
Easter Cookie Decorating Kit
USD 18.00
Halloween Paint Your Own Cookie
USD 4.00
Cookie Decorating Kit
USD 18.00
Ghost Cookie Set
USD 8.00
Elf Cookies
USD 5.00
Squishmallow Christmas Set
USD 40.00
Personalized Tumbler
USD 3.50
Buckeyes
USD 12.00
Valentine's Cookie Sets
USD 8.00
Valentine's Macaron Flight
USD 15.00
Fresh Baked Jumbo Cookie Flight
USD 15.00
Wedding or Event Order Deposit
USD 100.00
Easter Cookies- 1 Dozen
USD 34.00
Easter French Macarons
USD 24.00
Giant Sugar Cookies
USD 4.50
Party Platters
USD 50.00
Christmas Trees
USD 30.00
Freeze Dried Skittles
USD 4.50