Betty Bakery
A touch of retro & modern, a tribute to all that is mid-century mien & deliciousness; baked goods like treats that came out of our grandma’s kitchen, updated.
Browse by category
Collections
Cookies and Bars
Holiday - Rosh Hashanah
Holiday - Passover
Savory Pies
Cakes
Cupcakes
Large Fruit Pies
Holiday - Valentine's Day
Gluten Free Cakes
Retro Goodies
Gender Reveal Pastries
Vegan
Holiday - Thanksgiving
Holiday - Christmas
All Products
Classic Cakes
Specialty Cakes
Decorated Cakes
Birthday Cakes
Mothers Day
Pies
Misc
Mardi Gras
Small Fruit Pies
Signature Cakes
Holiday - Halloween
Holiday - Easter & Passover
Featured products
Popular right now
Individual Cupcakes
USD 4.50
Twinkies
USD 4.75
Ring Dings
USD 7.00
Carrot Cake
USD 70.00
Red Velvet Cake
USD 70.00
Walnut Brownies
USD 3.75
Lemon Coconut Bars
USD 3.95
Large Cookies
USD 3.75
Lemon Tart
USD 5.95
Chocolate Caramel Tart
USD 6.45
Apple Rustics
USD 7.50
Double Crust Apple Pie - 10"
USD 60.00
NY Sour Cherry Pie - 10"
USD 50.00
Pecan Pie -10"
USD 52.00
Award Winning Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie - 10"
USD 49.00
Lemon Bundt Cake
USD 60.00
Coconut Cake
USD 75.00
Valrhona Chocolate Cake
USD 70.00
Strawberry Shortcake
USD 70.00
Vanilla w/ Vanilla Buttercream
USD 70.00
Rugelach (per lb)
USD 38.00
Traditional Betty Bakery Buche de Noel
USD 175.00
Pumpkin Bread
USD 25.00
Cranberry Walnut Teabread
USD 25.00